‘Shoulder Season’: Novel Tells Fictional Story At Historic Lake Geneva Playboy Club Hotel

By Christina Clancy | October 7, 2021

  • Madison Author Christina Clancy's novel "Shoulder Season" was released in July 2021. Although a work of fiction, it takes place at the historic former Playboy Club Hotel in Lake Geneva. (Maureen McCollum/WPR)

Madison author Christina Clancy's novel "Shoulder Season" was released in July 2021. Although a work of fiction, it takes place at the historic former Playboy Club Hotel in Lake Geneva. (Maureen McCollum/WPR)

Listen Online

The Playboy Club Hotel opened in Lake Geneva in 1968. Not only did it bring celebrities to southeast Wisconsin, but it became a hub for Midwestern travelers and businessmen and, of course, Playboy Bunnies. Author Christina Clancy of Madison has released a novel called, “Shoulder Season,” that takes place at the historic resort, in the nearby town of East Troy, and in Palm Springs.

She tells the story of fictional 19-year-old Sherri Taylor who enters a period of self-discovery while working as a Bunny, and explores how, forty years later, she looks back on the experience, and the tragedy she blames herself for. In this excerpt from the book, Sherri has just begun her job as a Bunny, and she learns that the job — and the resort — are a lot different than she’d imagined.


A few days into training, Sherri understood why Gloria, the Bunny Mother, didn’t want to use the word “waitress” to describe the work the Bunnies had to do. What waitress trained for an entire week, or stayed up late trying to memorize the contents of two huge binders that were bigger than the Old Testament? Memorization was easier for Sherri than for most of the other girls. She was able to take a mental picture of just about anything she saw and store it in her brain, but still she was overwhelmed by all the rules Bunny Starr ticked through. “Don’t let guests see you wear jewelry, chew gum, eat, or sit. You’ll get demerits for having dirt under your nails, if your ears are bent incorrectly, if you don’t keep your locker organized, or if you don’t keep the changing room clean. You need to look at the bulletin board every day for updates and attend Bunny Council meetings. And don’t ever forget to check the ashtrays.”

Bunny Council sounded important. They had their own employee newsletter, called “The Hare’s Head.” Wouldn’t her friend Jeanne be impressed to learn that there was more to Sherri’s job than strutting around in a Bunny suit? Sherri had underlined a line she’d found in the Bunny Manual twice, once for herself, and once for Jeanne: “The Bunny has become what the Ziegfeld girl was to another generation, synonymous with the most glamorous young women in the world.” She was part of a tradition. She was finally part of something.

Former Playboy Bunny Pam Ellis, or Bunny JoJo. She worked at the Lake Geneva Playboy Club Hotel and worked as a consultant on Christina Clancy's novel, "Shoulder Season." (Courtesy of Christina Clancy)

Former Playboy Bunny Pam Ellis, or Bunny JoJo. She worked at the Lake Geneva Playboy Club Hotel and worked as a consultant on Christina Clancy’s novel, “Shoulder Season.” (Courtesy of Christina Clancy)

Sherri even got benefits. She felt like a real adult filling out her forms for accident, life, and health insurance. She had a week’s paid vacation and a free subscription to “Playboy” magazine that she could read two weeks before the subscribers. Guests could practically eat for free with Sherri’s family discount, but this perk only made Sherri sad that she didn’t know anyone who would visit her. Sherri was told she would be welcome at the Playboy Clubs in Chicago and Los Angeles and all over the world. When she heard this, she smiled at Rhonda. “We should go to Chicago.”

“That’s OK,” Rhonda said. “I went there on a school field trip to see the King Tut exhibit. I couldn’t stand all the shadows.”

“The shadows?”

“From the skyscrapers. The middle of the day in the city feels like the middle of the night. And the El is so loud. I’d be fine if I never went back there again. The loudest thing I hear in Barneveld is a screech owl. That’s enough for me.”

The most important rule, and the one that bothered Sherri the most, was that Bunnies were forbidden from dating not just coworkers, but also keyholders and guests. The women broke out in a collective groan of disappointment when they heard this.

“We’re disappointingly moral here,” Bunny Starr said in a voice that could break up a party. Disappointing was right: Sherri had had a million crushes on the boys at school, and she’d daydreamed about encounters with celebrities like Leif Garrett and Shaun Cassidy. Her notebook was filled with her signature with the last name of whichever boy she liked at the time: Sherri Parker, Sherri Hackbarth, Sherri McBride, all with a heart as the dot for the i in “Sherri.” But, aside from Tommy, she’d had little experience. She didn’t know how to flirt, much less act sexy. She’d hoped to change all that—wasn’t the resort supposed to be the sexiest place on earth? But with all the rules, she felt like the mystique around Playboy was a total lie. Rhonda seemed relieved, while Sherri felt she’d been betrayed. “We may as well have joined a nunnery,” she whispered to Ginger.

“Don’t worry,” Ginger said. “We’ll find a way to have fun.”


SONG: “Megeve” by Henry Mancini

Christi Clancy

Christina Clancy

Christina Clancy is the author of “The Second Home” and “Shoulder Season.” Her work has appeared in “The New York Times,” “The Washington Post,” “The Chicago Tribune,” “The Sun Magazine” and in various literary journals. She lives in Madison with her family.

Sign Up Form

Sign Up for Our Bi-Weekly Newsletter

Get your favorite Wisconsin Life stories, meet the crew, and go behind the scenes.

Our Favorite Collections

Storyteller Rodney Lambright II's comic series about the rich relationship between a single father, his young daughter and his retirement-age parents.
For the 150th anniversary of the Civil War, we discover how Wisconsinites experienced the war both at home and on the battlefield.
Ice, cold and winter are an integral part of what it means to live in Wisconsin. "Ice Week" explores the many ways that ice defines us.
Food plays a central part in many holiday traditions. This series honors the foods and meals that make the day.
Escape winter with a look at some of Wisconsin's favorite sports and games.
"Living the Wisconsin Life" is an online series exploring the little things that make living in Wisconsin fun, interesting and meaningful.